Originally Posted by John Kennett
What do you think of the format? How much "answer" should there be, and how much should rely on previous discussions? As ever, any suggestions are welcome.
Excellent concept and I particularly like the idea of having “links to the relevant discussions”. This will save searchers , myself included, a lot of time. Well done.
Regarding your request for an opinion on the format:-
As to the “answer” , I suggest that it may be more appropriate to have the thread debates as the “answer” and let the reader draw their own conclusions from the discussions on the linked threads.
After all, whoever puts up the “answer” has their own opinion and can be biased in their views in drawing a conclusion, thus possibly misleading the reader and causing further debate.
Some “questions” are black and white (or should be) like your Thames speed question but others can be much more subjective.