Performance - What Can I Expect?

[Phil M]

So I've decided that, having upgraded almost everything else on my rib, its time to upgrade the hull and tubes (Can't help thinking about Trigger's broom). The typical sea state up this end of the world is choppy, which my current zodiac, although capable, isn't very comfortable in. I'm looking for a longer, deeper V hull so I can get out more and not be limited to a few trips a year. I'm very keen to keep my engine, as I've had it from new and it's only got 40 hrs on it.

I'm planning a shopping trip next week but could use some input from the forum before I go. Can anybody give me an idea of the performance I can expect from the following, with a Merc 115 4st (the current 2.1l model)?

Humber Destroyer 5.8
Destroyer 6m
Ocean Pro 5.7
Ribcraft 585
Vipermax 5.8 or 6.2

I know with the engine I have I'm not going to get stellar performance but my current boat tops out at about 37-38kts with light loads and to be honest it's fast enough. We rarely get seas calm enough to go flat out anyway.

Thanks,

Phil

[Orwell boy]

check out xs ribs ,they have prices on their site for hull only ,seem good english built ribs with a strong tornado heritage i think ,no expert but have been on a similar thought train

[jwalker]

It's going to depend more on the weight within the boat rather than the specific model of boat - console type, seating, fuel tank, anchors etc.
25-28ish knots for a well specced boat.

[Highland Haggis]

Originally Posted by jwalker

It's going to depend more on the weight within the boat rather than the specific model of boat - console type, seating, fuel tank, anchors etc.
25-28ish knots for a well specced boat.

I have just returned from a wee adventure down south​ and there seems to be a lot of ribcraft down there most of the 585 that I saw where 150/175 Suzuki if u are buying new most manafactorers will be more than happy for you to taste run rib just give them a call

[Xk59D]

i wouldn't put that engine on those boats.

Without knowing the max engine size of all the boats listed i would be wanting a merc 150 on them if they will take it and leave that engine on your current boat.

it isn't about top end really, just mid range and with a 6m ish boat that engine will struggle, i had the 100hp version of that engine on a 5.6.....wouldn't do it again unless a smaller boat.

[Phil M]

As stated, I'm not looking to change the engine. The max hp for most of them is 150hp. Max for the destroyer 5.8 and vipermax 5.8 is 130hp. I'd be looking for a double console and 4 jockey seats but generally go out lightly loaded. With the 5.8's I'm not that far of max hp. Will I really only get mid 20s?

Phil

Phil

[Xk59D]

i suspect you will see 30-32 ish knots on the boats mentioned with your current engine if i had to guess (which i am obviously). i suspect you won't like the performance of a deeper V/heavier boat and marginal power so be careful.

[Last Tango]

Originally Posted by Phil M

<<<Will I really only get mid 20s?>>>


Phil

No. Lightly loaded it'll do better than that. Probably between 30 & 35kn.

The issue is more the bottom end torque/hole-shot that might disappoint and that can be mitigated against to a degree by using a vented prop.. eg. Lazer, Tempest etc....

[Bigplumbs]

Originally Posted by Phil M

As stated, I'm not looking to change the engine. The max hp for most of them is 150hp. Max for the destroyer 5.8 and vipermax 5.8 is 130hp. I'd be looking for a double console and 4 jockey seats but generally go out lightly loaded. With the 5.8's I'm not that far of max hp. Will I really only get mid 20s?

Phil

Phil

I was out with orwell boy and he has a Yam 115 4 stroke on a 19 foot rib so similar size to what you are looking at. Lightly loaded he gets about 32 knots if I remember correctly

[Orwell boy]

check out yesterdays posted drone film on here ,mine is 115 on 19ft (5.8m) ,plenty fast enough for me ,seems plenty of power throughout range ,and i,d rather pay for a 4 cyl service than a six .

[Xk59D]

Erm....the mercury 150 is 4 cylinder, just saying.

I totally agree though, paying for those 2 extra plugs every 3 years is a twat on my v6.

[Orwell boy]

Originally Posted by Xk59D

Erm....the mercury 150 is 4 cylinder, just saying.

I totally agree though, paying for those 2 extra plugs every 3 years is a twat on my v6.

yes i appollogise for thinking after 115 everybody went to six cylinder ,was just stuck in a honda 100hp /highfield thought train (but of course thats all gone now ) ,
my ref to 4cyl versus 6 cyl is my local dealers seem to suggest £400 for a 4 cyl and 1.5 times money for 6 cyl ie £600 as per 4plugs x 1.5plugs = 6 plugs

[Phil M]

Just to close the thread properly here, I went for a destroyer 5.8, dual console, 4 jockeys, stainless frame, aux engine. Today's top end speed was about 35kts with the original 17" Ali prop. Revs hit 5800 to 5900rpm so there may be a bit of gain with a new prop. Hole shot was good still and on the plane in 5 or so seconds. I also think the engine can go up a hole.

All in all, it is no rocket ship but fast enough for my needs. Was reading 1.4 nm/l, so fairly frugal though.

Phil

[Xk59D]

Originally Posted by Orwell boy

yes i appollogise for thinking after 115 everybody went to six cylinder ,was just stuck in a honda 100hp /highfield thought train (but of course thats all gone now ) ,
my ref to 4cyl versus 6 cyl is my local dealers seem to suggest £400 for a 4 cyl and 1.5 times money for 6 cyl ie £600 as per 4plugs x 1.5plugs = 6 plugs

Never seen this but your dealer is way more than what I pay for a v6 serviced by my Suzuki dealer, it is about 250-275 quid a season for a normal service. Major service is more but way less than your 600 quid anyway, my last (only) major was £480 and that includes the fuel tank filters.

New mercury 250hp would be 800 quid service at your dealer.....shocking pricing.

[beerbelly]

Originally Posted by Phil M

Just to close the thread properly here, I went for a destroyer 5.8, dual console, 4 jockeys, stainless frame, aux engine. Today's top end speed was about 35kts with the original 17" Ali prop. Revs hit 5800 to 5900rpm so there may be a bit of gain with a new prop. Hole shot was good still and on the plane in 5 or so seconds. I also think the engine can go up a hole.

All in all, it is no rocket ship but fast enough for my needs. Was reading 1.4 nm/l, so fairly frugal though.

Phil

excellent bet your chuffed with your new toy happy boating

[Bigplumbs]

A couple of pics of the new boat would be nice

[Phil M]

I only have one to hand so here it is......



Phil M

[Xk59D]

Looks very tidy....enjoy

[beerbelly]

lovely that

[Bigplumbs]

Now that looks like a lovely Rig.... That Merc on the back looks just right

Dennis