Electric trolling 'devices'

jambo · 03 July 2012, 15:43

I admit not to knowing to much about these in relation to their capabilities. Can someone please enlighten me are they any good for say short tendering from shore to mooring or are they no good against wind & tide?

Nos4r2 · 03 July 2012, 16:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by jambo

I admit not to knowing to much about these in relation to their capabilities. Can someone please enlighten me are they any good for say short tendering from shore to mooring or are they no good against wind & tide?

Oars are more powerful and probably weigh less than the battery you'll have to carry

jyasaki · 03 July 2012, 16:29

Trolling motor? I've seen guys fishing nearshore with these; for getting to/from a moored boat, they're probably fine; but as Nos said, oars are a lot cheaper and less complicated.

jky

hadd · 03 July 2012, 18:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by jambo

I admit not to knowing to much about these in relation to their capabilities. Can someone please enlighten me are they any good for say short tendering from shore to mooring or are they no good against wind & tide?

It would be ok to use one on a small tender billy i used one on a 4.3 quicksilver rib when

& it was no good abit of wind & i was going backwards

jambo · 03 July 2012, 19:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by hadd

It would be ok to use one on a small tender billy i used one on a 4.3 quicksilver rib when

& it was no good abit of wind & i was going backwards

Tx Andy I kinda thought that so it is a no go as we do get some windy days in the 'west'.
Cheers
have a good wend

awa154 · 21 July 2012, 08:56

I have a 44lb thrust electric outboard on my 9' inflatable. It has 5 forward and 3 reverse speeds.

I use it on our hydrodam lakes. On calm waters, it goes ok. Speeds 1 &2 are very slow, 3 is good for trolling, about a brisk walking pace. 4 is about a jogging pace. 5th, it leaves a wake behind the inflatable and purrs along quite nicely.( in calm waters)

Unfortunately, 5th draws twice the amperage from the battery that 4th does. With the 100amp hour battery, I would get about 3 hours running using the 5th speed setting.

The motor manufacturers tell you, you can run a battery down by 80%. The battery makers say never draw off more than 50%, or the battery will pack up quickly. The battery, I use weighs 22kg. (48lb). The motor 7.4kg.

On the open lake in windy conditions with a good choppy surface, I need 5th to get anywhere. Infact I can row as quick as the motor will push, into a steady wind, ( maybe, not for as long tho)

I am going to replace it with a 2.5hp outboard. This will push the boat far faster than the electric motor, and a 4.5litre fuel can weighs a hellva' lot less than a deep cycle battery.

Been an interesting learning curve tho, The electric motor has some good points, I just haven't found them yet.

Dhf · 21 July 2012, 09:55

Why not build your own, Okay this guy may be a little crazy in his way, but what a clever engineer, I think there's a positive future with electric motorised devises these days, with battery teck improvements over the years, It's a matter of having the right combo, gel batteries would work better I reckon.

The SUPER GNARLY 4.75 hp electric outboard motor ~ ANGLE GRINDER ~ outboard conversion - YouTube

Here's a better set up.
The 30 hp Aquawatt - the world's most powerful electric outboard motor - Image 1 of 6

If they could get the price lower I think they'd sell more of these.

Torqeedo Electric Outboard Engines | Electric Motors from Torqeedo

Nos4r2 · 21 July 2012, 10:02

Gel batteries will just wear out very fast-they really aren't built for this kind of thing. .

Poly · 21 July 2012, 15:04

Jambo - by "Electric trolling 'devices'" - were you referring to this thread? http://www.rib.net/forum/f51/gone-very-quiet-49573.html I suppose its just the same - entertaining for a short while, but after a little of regular interaction soon becomes frustrating and eventually will end up getting locked away and never used!

jambo · 21 July 2012, 16:13

Hi poly I took inboard all the xdvise on here and others. Decided it was not for me finished up buying a second hand 3.3 Mariner.

Sent from my iPhone using Rib.net

awa154 · 21 July 2012, 20:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by jambo

Hi poly I took inboard all the xdvise on here and others. Decided it was not for me finished up buying a second hand 3.3 Mariner.

Sent from my iPhone using Rib.net

I had a 3.3 Mariner, then later a 3hp Yamaha. The Yammy had the advantage of the throttle twist on the tiller. Both had inbuilt tanks, so that would've been an advantage in a small inflatable

Why O Why did I ever sell either. Got stuff all for both, they could've sat in the garage.